Loading Lifted

Contingent workforce

Is your current enterprise staffing model ready for what's next? 7 signs to check

Portrait of Lee Willoughby

Lee Willoughby

Senior Marketing Director, Lifted

Portrait of Lee Willoughby

Lee Willoughby

Senior Marketing Director, Lifted

Portrait of Lee Willoughby

Lee Willoughby

Senior Marketing Director, Lifted

Published

Published

Read

Read

10 min

10 min

Colleagues ceelvrating the next step
Colleagues ceelvrating the next step

Key takeaways

  • This guide helps enterprise teams tell whether their current way of engaging contractors, freelancers, agency talent and outsourcing can keep up with growth, using seven signs and a 1-to-5 score. Changes to your model are best shaped with your own legal, tax and HR advisors.

  • An enterprise staffing model usually gets outgrown gradually, when a new country, a growth plan, swings in hiring demand or an audit asks for more than it was designed to give.

  • The seven signs show up as blurry spend, a workaround for every new location, slow starts, fill rates that hide turnover, overtime on permanent teams, no single owner and a model that restarts whenever worker type or geography changes. If more than three areas score 3 or below, the model may be ready for an upgrade.

  • A modern staffing model keeps a strong permanent core and flexes the rest through one accountable supplier that can engage independent contractors, agency talent, EOR hires, AOR arrangements, staff augmentation and outsourcing. Lifted, an Upwork company does exactly that.

The moments when a stronger staffing model creates the most value

Let’s say it’s the Monday after leadership signs off on the growth plan. The company is opening an office in Warsaw by spring, and someone asks you how fast you can staff it. The honest answer depends on which agency happens to have a relationship there and whether Legal has time to review the paperwork. Nobody built the program to be slow. It grew one sensible decision at a time and is now being asked to do something it was never designed for.

That Monday is one of several moments when an enterprise staffing model gets tested, and you may recognize more than one of these:

  • A new market, country, business unit or product line is on the way.

  • Leadership has approved a growth plan, a transformation program or a cost-reduction target, and the workforce is expected to scale up, change shape or cost less to support it.

  • Hiring demand is getting harder to predict, with project-based work, seasonal peaks, backfills and skills shortages.

  • More of the work is moving to contractors, freelancers, statement-of-work providers or outsourced teams.

  • Procurement, HR, legal and finance are asking different questions about the same workforce, and the answers sit in different systems or documents.

  • An audit, a works council discussion or a compliance review is approaching, and the team has to show who is engaged, under which contract and in which country.

  • Leadership wants a single view of external spend, headcount, risk and time-to-productivity.

  • Every new worker type or geography seems to need another agency, staffing firm, payroll provider, EOR or internal workaround.

  • A major launch or transformation program needs capacity the permanent workforce can’t supply.

Each of these is a natural point to ask whether your model can carry what’s coming, and the seven signs below can help you check.

Continue reading: Does your contingent workforce need a unified operating model?

7 signs your staffing model is ready to level up

Score each sign as you read, from 1 (a real strain) to 5 (we have this fully handled and automated).

1

Your external workforce spend is growing, but visibility is not

Let’s imagine the CFO stops you after a leadership meeting and asks what the company spent on external engineers in Germany last year. Finance can send invoices and HR can send a headcount list, but nobody can cut the numbers by skill, country or engagement type, so a few people lose a week building an answer nobody fully trusts.

When did you last get a straight answer to “what are we spending on external talent, and what do we get for it”? At scale, that blur can hide overspend and duplicate suppliers.

A model built to grow offers total workforce visibility from one place, so that question takes minutes. Could you answer it in one meeting today?

2

Every new location, worker type or business unit creates a new workaround

Imagine a regional manager in Brazil needs two engineers by the end of the month. There’s no standard route, so they find a local agency, someone approves the contract over email and a spreadsheet keeps track of the rest. It works, and everyone moves on. Then it happens in four other countries, each a little differently, and the model starts to run on exceptions and on a few people’s memory. That’s part of why the contingent workforce is still broken for many enterprises.

At enterprise scale, this can show up as slower onboarding, inconsistent paperwork from country to country and risk that stays out of sight until a review. Programs that grow well tend to treat a new geography or worker type as something the existing model already knows how to handle, with the structured approval process, reporting and supplier standards.

If you opened a new market next quarter, how much of the process would already exist?

3

You cannot mobilize the right talent when the business needs it

Say a launch gets approved on a Tuesday and the team needs three specialists within six weeks. The request might then wait on the right agency and the right approver, and by the time talent starts, the window could have narrowed. Many teams recognize the capacity trap here, where the nearest staffing agency gets the call because it’s the fastest path anyone knows, even when it isn’t the best fit for the skill or the worker type.

A scarce skill or a new country can each call for a different route, and without clear ones the first specialist may arrive well after the work was meant to start. A flexible model keeps those routes ready so the business isn’t waiting on whoever happens to be available. For example, Lifted, an Upwork Company, is typically able to deliver an average time-to-fill of under 3 days through a flexible model.

What does approval-to-day-one look like for your team today?

4

Your fill rates look fine, but retention does not

Let’s say the monthly dashboard shows requests being filled on time, so on paper the supplier model is doing its job. Meanwhile a few hiring managers mention that the same roles keep coming back to the sourcing queue. Fill rate tells you a seat was taken. It can say very little about whether the person stayed, ramped up quickly or delivered what the team needed, and it may be that early assignment endings and repeat sourcing sit quietly underneath a healthy-looking number.

For an enterprise, those repeats can add up to repeated sourcing effort, and the rework hiring managers quietly absorb can easily slow projects down. Staffing programs that scale tend to track retention and time-to-productivity next to fill rate, and review them by supplier and by role.

What might you see if you pulled early assignment endings from the last two quarters?

5

Your permanent teams are stretched thin or on overtime to cover gaps the contingent model could handle

Take a project that starts before the contractors do. Someone has to cover, and it’s often the permanent team, who may put in extra evenings or the occasional weekend to keep things moving. At first that can look like great commitment, and in many cases it is. Over a few months, a steady pattern of overtime can leave people feeling stretched and can start to affect deadlines and morale.

It can be worth noticing where overtime keeps showing up on core teams, because it may hint that the workforce mix no longer matches the work. A modern staffing model keeps a strong permanent core and brings in flexible capacity, such as staff augmentation, to cover peaks.

How are your permanent teams feeling the load right now, and where could extra capacity make their year easier?

6

No one owns the end-to-end external workforce

In many enterprises, HR holds one part of the picture while procurement holds the contracts. Hiring managers choose the talent, legal reviews the terms and each agency or staffing supplier keeps its own records. Every group does its job well, and still a simple question from a leader, like who is engaged across the whole external workforce and how, has to be stitched together from five places.

That can feel more noticeable when an audit or a works council discussion is on the calendar and the team needs to show who is engaged and how. Programs that scale often have one owner and one shared view that every function works from, and consolidating suppliers under one accountable partner can make that easier.

At your company, could one person speak for the whole external workforce this afternoon?

7

Your model cannot change worker type, geography or scale without starting over

Let’s say a project that began with two independent contractors suddenly needs twelve people across three countries, with some of the work better suited to a statement-of-work provider or an outsourced team. For many programs that’s the week everything restarts: a new supplier and a new contract, then a process drawn from scratch. In countries where the company has no entity of its own, some of those people may need to be engaged through an Employer of Record (EOR), which can mean yet another provider and onboarding process, depending on the country and role.

A model that starts over whenever the business changes shape can be rigid when you need it to bend, and the cost can be speed. A scalable model lets you engage independent contractors, agency talent, EOR hires, AOR arrangements, staff augmentation and outsourcing through one supplier as demand shifts. For example, Lifted, an Upwork Company, is a tech-enabled contingent workforce supplier that can engage all these worker types, supported by its proprietary technology.

Could you change your mix next month without rebuilding anything?

How to stress-test your current staffing model and spot signs you've outgrown it

Score each sign from above from 1 to 5 in a notes app or spreadsheet, then compare your answers with the table below, which describes what a 5 and a 1 can look like. If more than three areas score 3 or below, your current model may be ready for an upgrade and a more scalable approach.

Sign

Closer to a 5 when…

Closer to a 1 when…

Spend growing, visibility not

Spend, worker type and outcomes can be reported by skill, geography and business unit from one place

Invoices and headcount exist, but cost by skill, geography or engagement type takes days to assemble

New workaround for every new need

A new location or worker type follows a process that already exists

Each new need brings a one-off supplier, manual approvals and local know-how

Slow to mobilize talent

Approved requests reach a first day of work quickly, with clear routes by worker type

Requests wait on the right agency, contract type or approver

Fill rate fine, retention not

Retention and time-to-productivity are tracked next to fill rate

Early assignment endings and repeat sourcing are common

Permanent teams stretched or on overtime

Peaks are covered by flexible capacity, and overtime is occasional

Overtime and delayed projects on core teams are regular

No end-to-end owner

One owner and one shared view across HR, procurement, legal and finance

Questions about external workforce risk and spend take several people to answer

Cannot change type, geography or scale

Worker type, geography or scale can change without a new supplier or process

Adding a worker type or a country means starting over

If the model is sound but your current supplier cannot support it, the issue may be the supplier relationship rather than the staffing model. Changes to your model are best developed with your own legal, tax and HR advisors.

What a modern, future-ready enterprise staffing model looks like

It helps to start with what stays the same. A strong permanent core handles the work only your own people can do, such as the institutional knowledge and the roles that define how the company runs. Around it sits flexible capacity that can grow or shrink with demand, so a launch, a new country or a seasonal peak doesn’t pull your core team away from its own work.

The flexible layer can include independent contractors, agency talent, EOR hires, AOR arrangements, staff augmentation and outsourcing, ideally engaged and governed in one system rather than through a growing list of separate agencies and one-off arrangements. Many enterprise teams find that one accountable partner for the workforce mix and workflows you need to scale captures what they are after, with spend, worker types and engagement details visible in one place and a model that can sit alongside an existing VMS or MSP rather than replacing it.

For example, Lifted, an Upwork Company, is a tech-enabled contingent workforce supplier that can serve as one supplier across independent contractors, agency talent, EOR, AOR, staff augmentation and outsourcing, with spend and worker data visible in one place through its proprietary technology.

We’re happy to show how Lifted can support your enterprise’s program. If you’d like to talk it through, reach out to our team.

See why leading enterprises choose Lifted

Explore Lifted's full CWMS platform or review our client case studies to see how enterprise organizations are transforming their contingent workforce programs with Lifted.

See why leading enterprises choose Lifted

Explore Lifted's full CWMS platform or review our client case studies to see how enterprise organizations are transforming their contingent workforce programs with Lifted.

See why leading enterprises choose Lifted

Explore Lifted's full CWMS platform or review our client case studies to see how enterprise organizations are transforming their contingent workforce programs with Lifted.

Frequently asked questions

  • What is a staffing model?

    A staffing model is the way an organization sources and engages its workforce, including the mix of permanent employees, agency talent, in-house teams, and contingent workers such as independent contractors and staff augmentation. You can compare the options in our contract staffing models comparison and see how the pieces fit in the contingent workforce operating model.

  • When should you change your staffing model?

    When to change your staffing model often becomes clearer once several of the seven signs start moving in the wrong direction together over two or three quarters. A single sign, like a slow start on one launch, can be a one-off. When spend visibility slips and workarounds pile up in the same stretch of time, many enterprise teams take that as a cue to look at the model itself. If you score 3 or below in more than three areas, it may be a good moment to talk with your procurement and HR partners about what a more flexible approach could look like.

  • Is a flexible contingent model cheaper than hiring full-time?

    Whether a flexible contingent model is cheaper than hiring full-time depends on the role, duration, geography, utilization and total cost of ownership, and it can come out higher or lower. For example, Lifted, an Upwork Company, is typically 10-30% cheaper than standard legacy suppliers. That comparison is against suppliers, not against full-time hiring, so your own total cost of ownership may be the better yardstick for that question. You can read more about Lifted’s contingent workforce technology.

Author

Portrait of Lee Willoughby

Lee Willoughby

Senior Marketing Director, Lifted

Lee Willoughby is the Senior Marketing Director at Lifted, an Upwork company helping enterprises source, engage, and manage contingent talent across every contract type. With a background as a co-founder and workforce technology entrepreneur, Lee focuses on the future of contingent workforce management, helping organizations navigate the complexities of global talent, compliance, and workforce transformation.

This content is for general informational purposes only, and is not intended to be and should not be viewed as legal or tax advice. Readers should contact their attorney or tax professional to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal or tax matter. Information discussed can change frequently, and Lifted cannot guarantee that all information is current at all times.

Get insights from global industry leaders.
Get insights from global industry leaders.
Get insights from global industry leaders.